Samatha trust, yogavacara, Paul Dennison

from dhammawheel:

Samvara: the Samatha Trust teach a single method of distinctive meditation. It’s normally taught in person by a designated teacher, and there is a tradition of practising in groups (either in-person or online via Zoom) and of “reporting” to one’s teacher to check the practice is going OK. It comes from the Yogāvacara tradition in Thailand, and was brought to the UK by a man named Nai Boonman. He and his early British followers managed to preserve this part of “Pre-Reform” Buddhist practice which - as you say - was largely supplanted by Vipassana techniques which followed the Thai reforms and “caught the wave” of Western popularity.

1 Like

https://www.dhammawheel.com/viewtopic.php?p=668636&hilit=Paul+Dennison#p668636
[samvara] I’ve been practising the method taught by the Samatha Trust for some years now. A while ago I attended a workshop run by them that was specifically about attaining jhānas. (Well, who wouldn’t try it?) They are your standard western middle-class well-educated professionals, just like the other loose groupings of Buddhist practitioners that I have known, with possibly a higher proportion of academics, doctors, psychologists, and the like. Paul Dennison (the author of the linked academic article) is one of the senior teachers, and although I have never met him outside of Zoom, the other teachers refer to him a lot.

Anyway, to cut a long story short, the meditation technique was well taught on this workshop, but I was somewhat taken aback by how quickly the advanced practitioners could access what they termed were jhānas. (“OK, for this next session we’ll be entering first jhana again, but not staying there too long. I’ll give the word, and we’ll drop vitakka and vicāra and move straight on up to second jhāna…”). As per usual, I just felt happily calm and peaceful as a result of concentrating on the breath, but the advanced lot very quickly looked as if they were, one after the other, starting to have seizures. Rhythmic twitching, panting, shaking, and in some cases bouncing up and down several inches into the air. Having just Googled what the clonic part of a tonic clonic seizure looks like, that’s what appeared to be happening. Including to the doctors and psychologists, and nobody - apart from me - seemed to think it strange. A reference was made to some people (but not all, due to kammic differences) experiencing a sudden uncontrollable surge of pīti which had this effect.

Of course, with my typical English fear of not being thought broad-minded, I nodded sagely. I even felt a bit left out. Should I try faking it in order to fit in?

So the questions remain. Are Dennison et al experiencing jhāna and everyone else who claims to experience it are wrong? And if so, why does the Buddha - and the commentaries - not mention these “side effects”? Or are they training themselves down a blind alley of inducing clonic seizures which are nothing to do with jhāna? Or have they somehow self-selected to create a small safe space for epileptic meditators? Are they all faking it because they have read Dennison’s article and also see this behaviour as a means of claiming they are expert meditators?

It’s very odd that I have never, in many years of retreat-going in different traditions, seen anything like this elsewhere. I once knew a monk who was subject to rapid jerky movements during meditation, but that was different and was associated with a type of neurological or mental illness.

1 Like

I’m not in tune with pop culture enough to make one, but it really feels like there is a meme in there somehow.

1 Like

Does not sound correct to me.
I vaguely remember reading something by them on the 24 paccayas. It was simple and good. I could not find it on the website.

The TM people try to “hop” while in a sitting posture when their meditation is “going good”. Perhaps something similar is happening.

I think they also sponsored Ajahn Sumedho to come to the UK and that was how Chithurst Moanstery started.

:laughing:
It sounds odd to me.

I believe that was the English Sangha Trust.

The English Sangha Trust, the stewards and owners of the Vihara, had been established in 1956 with the express aim of providing a suitable residence for bhikkhus in England. By 1972, this aim had not been achieved, and it was time to consider why. In some people’s minds, in fact, it now seemed an impossibility.

https://www.dhammatalks.net/Books2/Ajahn_Sumedho_Cittaviveka.htm#HOW

1 Like

From a link on the samatha.org
Yogāvacara Talks | Samatha Buddhist Meditation
https://itipiso.org/

The teaching of Buddhist meditation in the West has developed strongly since the 1960s, such that there is now widespread familiarity with words such as “mindfulness" and “vipassanā". A very basic approach to mindfulness, for example, is used in mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, (MBCT) introduced into the UK Health Service in 2010 as a treatment for recurrent depression. Vipassanā for a while became a catch-all term for Buddhist meditation, particularly in the 1960s and 70s, and it is only relatively recently that samatha meditation is becoming better understood in the West.

The development of meditation teachings in the West has also paralleled major upheavals in source countries such as Tibet, as well as reforms and upheavals in Southeast Asian countries such as Thailand, Cambodia, Burma, Laos, Vietnam and Sri Lanka. Some of the “reforms”, as in early 19th century Thailand when a new ordination line, the Thammayutika Nikāya, was formed, continued into 1950s Thailand with the two sects the Thammayutika Nikāya and the Mahā Nikāya vying for influence, seeking to modernise and Westernise Buddhist practices. This was at the expense of centuries-old esoteric practices related to the samatha tradition, suppressed in favour of the “dry” Burmese vipassanā practice which was heavily promoted in the 1950s.

Research in Cambodia by L’École Française d’Extrême-Orient (EFEO), and in particular by the French ethnologist François Bizot since the 1970s, has recovered a number of old palm-leaf manuscripts related to the older practices, with similar texts also found in Thailand and Sri Lanka. This has opened up an interest in what has come to be known as Tantric Theravāda, or Boran Kammathāna (ancient practices), or the way of the Yogāvacara. Because of the cryptic nature of these texts, which reflect only fragments of what has always been an oral tradition, there is great scope for misinterpretations and misunderstandings if taken out of context from direct meditation experience.

and this is from wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yog%C4%81 … 27s_manual
The Yogāvacara’s manual is a Theravada Buddhist meditation manual with unique and unorthodox features such as the use of mental images of the elements, the mantra “A-RA-HAN”, and the use of a candle for meditation. It has been loosely dated from the 16th to the 17th century.[1]

Overview
The text is addressed to a “Yogāvacara”, referring to any practitioner of Buddhist meditation and hence it is a practical meditation manual.[2]

The text covers Buddhist meditation material such as the ten recollections (anussati), the brahmaviharas, the five kinds of piti (joy), the four formless realms (arūpajhāna), the nimittas, and 10 vipassanā-ñāṇas.[3] It teaches a form of breath meditation in which one cultivates a bright perception of a nimitta at the tip of the nose and moves it down the body to the heart and then to the navel.[4] It also includes many other exercises such as meditation using a candle flame, kasinas and the use of mental images of the elements (mahābhūta).[5]

The single rare Pali and Sinhalese manuscript was discovered in 1893 at Bamabara-walla Vihara in Sri Lanka by Anagarika Dharmapala.[6] T.W. Rhys Davids of the Pali Text Society translated the text into English in 1896. It was later translated by F.L. Woodward as “Manual of a Mystic”. The manuscript has no information on the author and has no title.[7]

Some scholars like Francois Bizot have argued that this work is influenced by the esoteric Theravada tradition, though other such as Justin Thomas McDaniel find this assertion dubious.[8] Caroline Rhys Davids notes that in the 16th and 17th centuries monks from Siam were invited by the Kandyan kings to revive Buddhism in the island and states it is possible that the manual derives from this tradition.[

Kudos for my blog title which gets #1 ranking.

“Secret Teachings Theravada”

I left Mahayana with the thought. “These so-called basic teachings are more than I can absorb. I don’t need these extra advanced teachings.”

This is similar to how it’s taught in the Vimuttimagga.