Nanavira's ideas about Dependent Origination

An interesting phenomenon is the case of Nanavira, an English Bhikkhu of the 20th century whose unusual beliefs still come up occasionally on forums.

bp437s_Bodhi_Investigating-Dhammananavira compl.pdf (269.3 KB)

Bhikkhu Bodhi gives a good refutation in this file starting at p.39

1 Like

What I see, skimming Nanavira’s rather dense arguments, is that for him a vital issue is existential anxiety.

However, the Buddha explained the issue is this prison of saṃsāra, repeated birth, aging, and death. Existential anxiety may be a problem, but it is far from the main scope of paṭiccasamuppāda.

Anyway, Bodhi gives an exceptional and thorough examination, well worth the study.

1 Like