Heart base - or brain

As I said at the start:

I think as we learn more and confidence grows, interest gradually shifts to reality - to what life really is.

Anything else is merely ideas, concepts; and the mind has an almost unlimited capacity to manufacture simple or complex ideas - and can get very enamored with them.

If those concepts are about Dhamma they can have use but even then unless we are getting down to the real nitty gritty - that is learning to distinguish reality from concept then understanding won’t grow. There are only cittas, cetasikas and rupa, that is all.

It is interesting to learn more about the ayatana . For example seeing an object. This is the coming together of eyesense, visible object , seeing consciousness and cetaikas that accompany the citta. And each of these is conditioned. It happens utterly beyond anyone’s control. That extremely brief moment of seeing can only arise at the tiny kamma produced rupa at the center of the eye - if that special rupa is not present then no seeing can ever arise.
And the same for a moment of experiencing hardness through the body - just different realities- citta, cetasikas and rupa.

Damage to the brain impairs the formation of dhammas cognized by consciousness.

Even a snake or an ant has seeing- cakkhu-vinnana (cakkhuviññāṇa)- merely an element that must arise if there are conditions. Someone might have severe brain damage - but still seeing arises, thinking arises, smelling, tasting ..
Unless there is the coming together of the eyesense, and the visible object seeing will never happen. A blind man who is without the eyesense can never have cakkhu vinnana.

Madhupindika Sutta MN 18

Dependent on the ear and sounds…Dependent on the nose and odours.. .Dependent on the tongue and flavours.. .Dependent on the body and tangibles…Dependent on the mind and mind- objects, mind-consciousness arises. The meeting of the three is contact. With contact as condition there is feeling. What one feels, that one perceives. What one perceives, that one thinks about. What one thinks about, that one mentally proliferates. With what one has mentally proliferated as the source, perceptions and notions tinged by mental proliferation beset a man with respect to past, future, and present mind-objects cognizable through the mind.

Thus six different worlds - seeing this has many benefits:

Therefore, Bāhiya, this is how you are to train yourself:
“In the seen, there will be just the seen.
In the heard, there will be just the heard.
In the sensed, there will be just the sensed.
In the cognized, there will be just the cognized.
This, Bāhiya, is how you are to train yourself.

The fact that you are reading this requires the internet and a materialistic device connected to it, all thanks to modern science.

It sounds like modern science thinks feeling (vedana ) is a type of physical entity: This pain that seems to be arising at the area where the cut was somehow migrates up to the brain ?

Its cause is purely physical. Thanks to materialism we have all the advances in pain reduction and anasthesia for example. Imagine having a surgery without any pain killers.

The pain does NOT migrate anywhere, it is a signal that gets send to the brain which interprets it as pain. If the nerve along which the signal travels is blocked, or the signal somehow altered, or specific region in the brain that deals with pain has its function altered - then there can be pain reduction or even no pain.

Even a snake or an ant has seeing-

Not every type of ant has eyes or ears.

Interesting thing about snakes: They have infrared vision, they see heat. Also Ultraviolet (something we don’t see) and some color vision on the level of color blindness in humans.

1 Like

And as I said in the next sentence,
“All of us are much conditioned by an age where scientific discoveries seem so testable and provable. It is natural that doubts arise on this matter”.

Is this pain signal mentality or materiality? Do you agree with the quote from the Commentary: > (Nidaanavagga) VII The Great Subchapter 61

(1) Uninstructed (1) p. 595 Samyutta Nikaya Vol 1 (translated by Bhikkhu Bodhi) "
note 157: Spk: one citta is
not able to endure for a whole day or a whole night. Even in the
time of a fingersnap many hundred thousand kotis of cittas arise and
cease (1 koti=10 million).

There are many conditions needed for a moment of kaya viññāṇa (bodily consciousness). It is similar to seeing - without light visible objects cannot appear. Or if the eyebase is impaired for some reason even briefly then visible object won’t appear. Similarly if the kayavatthu is impaired then no body consciousness can arise at the area where it is impaired (for example if a limb is paralysed or if someone was under anesthetic).
Without understanding Dhamma we would always think that “I” am looking at this or that but the commentary to the Sammanaphala sutta (The Fruits of Recluseship, Bhikkhu Bodhi), talking about looking ahead or looking aside, breaks this down into various conditions as explained in the Patthana.

The eye is a support condition: forms are an object condition; adverting is a proximity, contiguity, decisive support, absence, and disappearance condition; light is a decisive support condition; feeling etc are conascence conditions. Thus looking ahead and looking aside are discerned in the assemblage of these conditions.

And also for kaya viññāṇa (bodily consciousness) there is the incredibly brief meeting of the tangible data base (hardness, heat etc) , the kayavatthu (body base) and the kaya viññāṇa.

Vism. XVII
85. The tangible-data base is a condition, as prenascence condition, for the body-consciousness element and for the states associated therewith..[..]

And other conditions are involved: the body-base (kāyavatthu) is the support condition; tangible datum (phoṭṭhabba—hard/soft, hot/cold, pressure/motion) is the object condition; adverting (āvajjana) functions as proximity, contiguity, decisive-support, absence, and disappearance conditions; the earth element (paṭhavī-dhātu, i.e., ‘solidity/extension’) is a decisive-support (upaniṣsaya) for the arising; and the co-arisen mental factors—feeling, perception, volition, etc.—are conascent (sahajāta) . And these are present for the brief meeting and then immediately cease and new conditions arise.

What is the purpose of defining all these conditions?: It is a step in learning that there are only these conditioned elements, no self.
As the Tika to the Sammanaphala sutta says:

Looking ahead and looking aside being discerned by way
of the five aggregates, who is it, separate from those aggregates, that looks ahead? Who looks aside? The meaning is: there is no one who looks ahead, no one who looks aside p.118 of Bodhi translation

Thus there is benefit in seeing life through this lens, to see that there is only mentality - materiality. We may be satisfied with what we learn from science but unless there is the development of understanding of what is really present we remain anchored to the conceptual world with all its assumptions.

1 Like

14 posts were split to a new topic: Brain and scientific beliefs

x nervous system—don’t appear to be necessary for learning, according to new studies:

While the study does not definitively show that the mental consciousness base is in the heart, it clearly does show that a brain is not necessary for learning or memory.

https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64…
https://www.cell.com/action/showPdf?p…
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.11…
https://www.nature.com/articles/s4200…

These are quite strange findings for sure, but they do dispel the myth that a brain or a central nervous system are necessary for learning.

R

1 Like

And where does it say in the suttas that consciousness is in the brain?
I don’t think you will find anything. That is why there are 31 parts.

In one of my Sunday talks, I mentioned that the consciousness takes place in many parts of the body. Eyes, ears.. and all sense doors including the whole body.

I had said “it is constantly moving its place” in conventional language, but it is really constantly arising and passing in other places since consciousness does not move. Kalapas do not move. “Animated” pixels on a screen do not move.

The question is actually, where does the mind-door take place. That is said to be in the blood located in the heart.
It is a standard question for Pa-Auk Yogis to be asked as they go through the nāma course. I think all or nearly all agree that it is the heart.

3 Likes

A few days ago, I listened to a Dhamma lecture that mentioned the mind is present in the blood inside the heart.

My understanding is that after the heart is removed, the mind can still dwell in the blood that flows through that area.

Consciousness (vinnana / citta) is not local, so it can be anywhere in the body (i.e., the six sensory organs). Citta is present at whatever that gets attention (or intention to sense).

Keep watching you body and mind and one day you might work it out. Consciousness is so cool it is not easy to say where it is. But we know it exists. And there are 6 types of it to make you look harder. What they say exists in the heart is the hadaya vatthu. Consciousness just knows. It looks to me as a lesson in relativity. Somethings maybe can’t be known. But consciousness is definitely conditioned impermanent, suffering and not me, not mine, not self.

Mind and body rise and fall together at the same. You will know this when you practice anapanasati. The air touches the nose and you know - from start to end. When the air does not touch the nose, you know. That is how you know the way mind and body rise together and fall together.

actually they are very different. Take visible object or sound: these rupas have to arises before the cakkhu vinnana (seeing consciousness) or sota vinnana arises to experience them. And when visible object or sound is experienced through the mind-door it has just fallen away.

That is only body consciousness. When you think “may all beings living in happiness and peace, may all beings experience happiness”. Where is that located? Feels like it is in my head to me. When you read these words where is the understanding of the meaning of it located? And where does it go? Where are your dreams located?

Yes when you see an object in the distance or even in your own room. Where is your seeing consciousness located? When I hear the birds chirping outside where is my hearing consciousness of it located?

seeing consciouness, cakkhu vinnana can only arise at the eyebase, the tiny kamma produced materiality in the centre of the physical eye.

Yes that is the theory from an ancient past. I do 32 parts of the body not 31. I am constantly amazed by how detailed the list is as a person who studied biology. That the Buddha had such a detailed knowledge of parts is very cool indeed. I have been to autopsies and seen some brains in my time. I think if we combine the mordern with the old we get an interesting mix. Without your brain which is hooked into you retina via optic nerves you won’t “see” anything. So eye consciousness with all its spaciousness and beauty and 3 characteristics is likely in your brain. In the 32 parts there are no nerves. The majority of which lead to the brain. We have access to a much better understanding of biology and biochemistry because of science we can also use it to understand our own consciousness better with the use of some Dhamma. I think they compliment and enhance each other and force us to move to new modern models than just clinging to the old stuff. It is like the blind men touching a different part of an elephant and describing what they felt. None of them is really wrong.

The rupa which has not been detected (or come into contact) by vinnana is not known (one does not know it). These rupa rise and fall all over space, including inside the body.

Rupa that is detected by vinnana must have arrived to vinnana, in the form of a sensory object.

So, there is contact (phassa). This is where nama and rupa rise together and fall together. All six sensory processes are the same - a sensory object coming in, has contact with consciousness, knowing happens. In the knowing, nama and rupa rise together and fall together.

Consciousness does not happen before sensory contact.

Only when there is contact, there is consciousness.

So, at the contact, consciousness and the sensory object rise together and disappear together. Consciousness does not arise before the sensory object has appear and does not persist after the sensory object has disappeared.

A post was split to a new topic: Different consciousness’ overlap?

So the mind is the observer which is why I used that phrase. This is where rigid systems from the past fail to account for reality in the light of new knowledge. You have every sense in your body wired with nerves to your brain and yet you stick with a heart model.. Either way doesn’t matter but it makes you look out of touch with reality. There is other stuff that is even more mind blowing but you are stuck in a model that is not really a complete or accurate explanation.

Is a computers ICU a place where nothing happens and the processing is somewhere else?

Dhamma is much better than abhidhamma because it does not suffer from that problem. It still fits with science and is a better description. Abhidhamma explains into a corner. Then there are other wondrous things in life like kamma and how it works. It is really on another level outside the scope of normal experience. “We are all the heirs of our own kamma and owners of our own kamma, kamma is the cause of whatever happens to us… whatever kamma we do good or bad of that we will the heir.” There is something wondrous about this realisation as it is not just 4 elements and not self. Our destiny on this path to finally release ourselves from the belief in self depends on our kamma of body, speech and mind and our practise of the noble eight fold noble path. So I think at some point we have to realise the Buddha was someone really special because he went beyond the thoughts of the day to a new way to look at things. It is so hard to do that but it requires a lot of good kamma.

I think you mean CPU.
The CPU (or at least earlier types) is separate from memory and separate from hard drives (data storage). There is no location for kamma in the body. If it were in the body, you would be free from kamma when you died.

You need to also understand that the Buddha never mentioned in the Suttas that the brain was a CPU either. Try to learn from Classical Theravāda. Please understand our views here and work within those ideals. We have a lot to offer, and so do you. But speaking like this in the above post pollutes our community. Try to contribute within our framework.

Yes CPU. Just a bit of a memory slip. ECU or ECM in automotive which I play with all the timeand a bit of a slipup. So what you are saying it that you have this framework where you don’t want to explore truth anymore but want to stay ignorant of other ways of looking at things? For me all knowledge is useful and reality is fascinating.